The Untouchable Dick Tracy


This entry is dedicated to the lovely Fay Wraith, my life partner in crime. She walked into the den while I was watching Republic’s Dick Tracy Returns (1938). As Ralph Byrd’s Tracy waded into a room full of thugs, she glanced at the screen and commented, “Oh, you’re watching Eliot Ness again.” It’s a perfectly understandable case of mistaken identity. Especially when you know the origins of plainclothes Tracy…
Chicago,1931 - Dick Tracy makes his comic strip debut in the Chicago Tribune, a paper whose front pages would have been filled with daily accounts of Eliot Ness and The Untouchables and their battle to put Al Capone behind bars and break the back of the Chicago Mob. No coincidence then. Even the trademark rogue’s gallery of cartoon villains like The Blank and Flat Top can be traced back to “Scarface” Capone.
As Tracy’s popularity grows, so too does the public’s fascination with real-life G-Men and their war against public enemies like John Dillinger and Pretty Boy Floyd. More and more papers pick up Tracy’s exploits. Republic wins the rights to produce the detective’s serial adventures, beginning with Dick Tracy in 1937. They even consider casting real-life G-Man Melvin Purvis in the lead role, before settling on actor Ralph Byrd.
The first Tracy serial is a huge success, prompting a sequel in 1938. Instead of the pulp-inspired Spider and his gang, Dick Tracy Returns draws its villains from the front page headlines. Pa Stark and his boys are obviously inspired by the notorious Ma Barker and her killer brood of murdering sons. This changes the tone of the whole serial. In fact it makes Dick Tracy Returns the only true hardboiled crime serial.
Serials almost always exist in a pulp fantasy world, one that appeals directly to 12-year old boys of all ages. By contrast, the first chapter of Dick Tracy Returns begins with newsreel footage of real G-Men firing tommy guns on a shooting range. (They fire short, measured bursts and aim low. It’s amazing what a kid can learn at the movies!) We see this as Dick Tracy shows the film to a classroom full of FBI recruits.
One of those recruits, (stuntman Dave Sharpe) is shot in the back by Kid Stark when he attempts to foil an armored car heist. When Pa Stark (Charles Middleton) finds out his sons didn’t make sure that Sharpe was dead, the Kid heads back and guns down the wounded G-Man again! Badly wounded, Sharpe is put into an iron lung. Once Pa Stark finds out, he sneaks into the hospital and pulls the plug.
This is a serial for children? It surely is. And though the hard-edged violence and nastiness of this first chapter is never quite equaled in the 14 chapters that follow, Dick Tracy Returns is a serial unlike any other. The action piles on fast and furious. Most of the Stark’s criminal schemes are all too real: extortion, blackmail, robbery, terrorism. When they threaten to blow up a planetarium, they don’t hesitate to murder a crowd of innocent visitors inside. That’s just “Too bad for them.”
Pa Stark and his sons are simply violent sociopaths, not the hooded madmen and super villains you’ll usually find in the serial world. One plot to kidnap a schoolbus full of children and hold them for ransom was considered so vile it never made it past the scripting stage. Accentuating the down-to-earth action is terrific location shooting. Shootouts and fistfights take place at airports, docks, an abandoned rock quarry and the now-famous Griffiths observatory.
All of the Dick Tracy serials are good, even great. Dick Tracy Returns, with its hard edge and fine performances from Byrd and Middleton, just may be the best. And if you want a double-dose of 30s crimebusting action with straight-shooting fedora-wearing heroes, pair it up with a black-and-white TV episode of The Untouchables (1959-1962). Any resemblance between Eliot Ness and Dick Tracy won’t be a coincidence at all.